District 9 – Alex’s Review

District 9You know what. I love cinema. I think cinema is greatest thing that mankind has ever produced. I think when used correctly cinema is the highest form of art that exists on this planet. Nothing gives me greater pleasure than watching a director so dedicated to his craft that he comes up with something truly remarkable.

Ladies & Gentlemen I give you Neill Blomkamp.

A 29-year-old South African who became friends with Peter Jackson and in doing so got him to produce a Sci-Fi masterpiece.

Blomkamp impressed Jackson so much that he hired him to direct Halo. A film based on the hugely popular computer game available on the Xbox. Unfortunately the budget for Halo spiralled way out of control and the film was shelved. It’s a very similar story to the problems that the Bioshock production has encountered.

Anyway with the Halo film gone Neill Blomkamp pitched the idea for District 9 to Peter Jackson. District 9 is itself based on a short Blomkamp had directed some years earlier called Alive In Joburg.

Alive in Joburg depicted the social struggles between humans and aliens in the city of Johannesburg using documentary style footage. Needless to say Peter Jackson was hooked and gladly signed on as producer for District 9.

District 9 is essentially a science fiction social satire. The fact the Neill Blomkamp based the script on his own childhood growing up in South Africa during Apartheid is no real surprise at all. It highlights everything that is wrong with human beings.

It shows anger, ignorance, violence, racism and prejudice but with one key twist that makes the film truly original and special.

District 9The story revolves around an alien spaceship that is stranded above Johannesburg. The extra terrestrials inside become refugees in the city and are placed in an area called District 9. This area is reminiscent of the slums that are common around poor parts of Johannesburg and even look strangely familiar to concentration camps.

The aliens are mistreated and violently abused by the human population. 20 years on and a law is passed where the aliens are to be removed and put into another area far from the city to live in small tents. The film is shot like a documentary. We get to see fake interviews with politicians, doctors and even the general public. The aliens are referred to as ‘prawns’ because of their appearance. This is a derogatory term used in exactly the same way as a human would when he or she is racially abusing someone else.

This is when we meet Wikus Van De Merwe played by Sharlto Copely. Wikus works for a munitions company called Multi-National United. He is put in charge of evicting the aliens but as we follow him being typically violent and abusive to the aliens he is accidentally exposed to a strange alien chemical that begins to change him into the very thing he hates most. He starts to become a ‘prawn’.

Now with the humans hunting him he must team up with two aliens to stay alive and in doing so he learns a few lessons along the way.

Honestly District 9 will leave you breathless. The minimal special effects blend seamlessly with live action. They aren’t overbearing in the slightest. It is like they actually belong in the shot. This is a far cry from the over-the-top CGI extravaganza that Michael Bay serves us in Transformers. This could very well be a real situation.

The way Blomkamp manages to bring so much depth and emotion to an alien race is astonishing. In particular the curiously named Christopher Johnson and his small son. I have never cared about two aliens so much before. I don’t even care as much for E.T. as I do for these two.

District 9The amazing thing is that these two aliens portray so much love and affection that it really highlights how detestable humans can be.

It’s a true testament to the script and of course the special effects team who have really outdone themselves here.

It’s also an amazing performance by amateur actor Sharlto Copely. His journey from bumbling ignorant racist buffoon to unlikely hero is joy to behold. The fact that it takes such extreme circumstances to change his whole perception on life makes him even more human.

It’s the age-old problem really. If the pain and suffering isn’t happening to you then all is well in the world.
The action is directed with such style. You won’t even pause to take a breath during some of the major set pieces. Neill Blomkamp does a brilliant job at showing us all the carnage of battle as limbs get torn apart and blood splatters all over the camera.

Are there any faults? Well inevitably yes, but nothing major.

Some of the interview scenes work against the film. They essentially slow the action down without elaborating on the story or telling us more about the characters.

The film also suffers when the documentary style shots disappear for awhile making way for conventional cinema. This makes the film slightly unbalanced.

The main problems consist of certain plot points throughout the film. Within District 9 there is a group of Nigerian gangsters who exploit the aliens by selling them food in exchange for alien technology. The leader of this group is obsessed with the aliens and wants to harness their power for himself. Throw in some voodoo magic and you pretty much end up with run-of-the-mill conventional bad guys. For a film that is trying so hard to break all the rules this seems a little bit disappointing.

Remember how bad Tommy Lee Jones was as Two-Face in Batman Forever? This is essentially the same thing.

District 9These are minor problems in an otherwise outstanding film. We really have been spoilt recently with Inglorious Basterds and now District 9.

This film can stand proud among other major Sci-Fi films like Blade Runner, Alien and Aliens. Before going to see it everybody seemed to be saying that District 9 is this years Cloverfield. Not at all, Cloverfield is good but this is stunning!

Oh and one more thing. Somebody give Neill Blomkamp some money because on this form Halo would be amazing!

Rating: ★★★★½ 

Make Current

Related Stories

About Alex Wagner

Alex lives in London and is a huge film geek. He studied courses at the NYFA ranging from Screenwriting, Editing and Film-Making. Alex has sold scripts to fellow students and worked on many small productions across the capital. Alex has great interest in Japanese cinema even going so far as calling Akira Kurosawa the greatest director that has ever or will ever live. He loves writing, watching films, travelling and football. Being an east Londoner it's West Ham all the way! With an extensive DVD collection and a supreme love for cinema Alex is incredibly happy to be part of the FILMSHAFT.COM team.
  • Mark Simms
    I agree with 99% of this review - I went into this film knowing pretty much nothing about it and it completely sucker punched me!! It really is an incredible piece of film making backed up with a great story, characters and pacing. To say the SFX are minimal is a bit skewed, there are hundreds of CGI shots in this movie, however if you meant it is there to serve a purpose and not thrown into your face for the sake of it then I would say you are bang on. The great thing here is there was no big reveal of the aliens, you see them from the outset, so you are not spending 50% of the film waiting to see them in their glory - which is a great as it stops us wondering what these ETs look like, the director gets it out of the way in the first two minutes, so instead of studying the CGI creatures, you just accept them as part of the film and that way we are more immersed in the production from the offset. However that isnt to say they are bad CGI, they are not, they look amazing with loads of small details and personality touches.

    Its not often I endorse a film as wholly as I have this one, but it was just such an incredible experience I can`t wait until I get my Blu-ray of it so I can watch it again.

    and again

    and again.

    etc.

    Also, if Blomkamp had been given this amount of creative reign over Halo then just from seeing the alient weaponary in this movie I think we would of been in for one amazing film - but if Halo wasn`t shelved we may of never been treated to this spectacle.
  • eiganomegami
    I can't believe I heard so many disparaging reviews of this film from people (invariably the same people who claimed that Transformers 2 was amazing and a must-see). Its brand of social commentary was effective in a way that few films have touched (Paul Haggis could learn innumerable things from this film about making statements on social problems through film).

    Even further, it combines social commentary with a staple of good Science Fiction--it raises possible issues of the future, especially the moral kind. While the emphasis, true, was largely on the social commentary, I think we need to see more of the latter it science fiction again. Aliens aside, as a society, even as a planet, we are barreling forward far faster than people can even think of developing legislation to keep up with it. Aside from entertainment value, Sci Fi is supposed to inspire consciousness of this kind--think Philip K. Dick (speaking of Bladerunner), William Gibson, even Tad Williams (especially Otherland). Sci Fi in cinema has been slacking in this regard.

    The film was especially refreshing as an original idea in a sea of remakes, comic book movies, and based-on-a-true-story films, the trend stooping to the point of the Battleship movie. Bravo on multiple points to D9!
  • Yeah, without a doubt one of the best Sci-Fi films ever made.
    I can't wait to see what Blomkamp does next!
  • Timo
    You're absolutly right. This movie blew my mind away and I still have to think about it, especially the sad and rethinkable ending.
    My major problem with the movie was that there was no deeper dialogue between Vikus and CJ or with his wife and some minor plot holes, but which scifi movie does not have them?

    Yeah, I also felt like you, caring for CJ and his son. This is the first time I had an emotional attachment and felt sadness for an alien.
    I really hope that Blomkamp will continue the story, it has so much potential for a District 10. Give Vikus his dignity back, show the alien planet, show the story from CJ's point of view like it did with Vikus in D9, make it 15 minutes longer and fill it with more story and dialogues.

    For me, District 9 is the best movie in 2009, maybe the best alien movie of all time but definitely one of the best sci fi films made in the last 10 years.
  • Shamim
    This is a very good review. I understand where Blomkamp is coming from and it's great to see someone put alot of how they see society and racial issues in a film. I also agree that this is what makes movies a great form of art.

    Again, great review. It's something i would expect to read in an issue of Empire. ;p
blog comments powered by Disqus